Looks for Less: Tried, Tested, and Truly Worth It
I love a great investment piece. I also love when something more affordable totally holds its own. This post is all about real-life comparisons. These are items I have personally used, worn, or tested, alongside their higher-priced counterparts. No guessing, no internet hearsay, just honest thoughts from my own closet, kitchen, and bathroom.
Some of these surprised me. And some of them may have made me question past spending decisions.
Jenni Kayne Sweater vs. Quince
I debated the Jenni Kayne sweater for about two years. I own other JK pieces and love them, but I already have a lot of sweaters, so it never felt like a full-body yes.
I opted for the Quince version instead, and it has become one of my most worn sweaters over the past nine months. It’s soft, warm, and so far has stayed pill-free. I truly love it. I also have clients who swear by the Jenni Kayne original, and it is a beautiful sweater. Bottom line: you really can’t go wrong either way.
Hallie’s verdict: Both are great. Quince is the smart buy if you already own plenty of sweaters.
Shop the Sweaters:
Loeffler Randall Heels vs. Dolce Vita
This nude sandal from Loeffler Randall is one of my most comfortable and versatile heels. The heel height is great, the straps are supportive, and it feels elevated without being overly dressy. On a cost-per-wear basis, they paid for themselves.
Dolce Vita came out with a very similar pair, so I ordered them in black. Turns out, they’re just as good. Both brands fit me well across multiple styles, which says a lot because I have finicky feet and a wider footbed.
Hallie’s verdict: Equal comfort, equal versatility. Dolce Vita is a win if you want options in multiple colors.
Shop the Sandals:
Veronica Beard Blazer vs. Quince
This Veronica Beard blazer is a true workhorse in my wardrobe. It also has a fun party trick: interchangeable dickey inserts that completely change the look. I almost always pack it for travel because it does so much.
I recently ordered the Quince version for a client on a tighter budget, and I was thrilled with how it performed. Dickey inserts included. For reference, I wear a 6 in Veronica Beard, but the Quince version ran more true to size and I would size down to a 4.
Hallie’s verdict: The Quince version absolutely delivers. Just size carefully and you’re set.
Shop the Blazers:
Frank & Eileen Sweatshirt Blazer vs. Amazon
I love the Frank & Eileen sweatshirt blazer. The quality, ethically sourced cotton, made-in-the-USA production, and B Corp certification all matter to me. I wear their pieces constantly, which makes the investment worth it.
That said, Amazon does have a solid look-for-less option. I can’t speak to the fabric quality or labor practices, but purely from a visual standpoint, it delivers the look.
Hallie’s verdict: Frank & Eileen for values and longevity. Amazon for the look alone.
Shop the Sweatshirt Blazers:
Nili Lotan Barrel Jeans vs. Other Options
I’ve been wearing barrel jeans for over seven years. They suit me, they make me happy, and despite the occasional internet outrage, they are the most worn pants in my wardrobe.
I love the Nili Lotan pair, but many brands now offer similar styles at lower price points. I’ve personally tried Everlane, and my daughter Maggie loves her pair from Gap. I’ve linked some of the best options so you can find what works for you.
Hallie’s verdict: The silhouette matters more than the label. Plenty of great options at lower prices.
Shop the Barrel Jeans:
Khaite Studded Bag vs. Evereve Studded Bag
I’m not typically a bag girl. Most of my bags are vintage. But I stay very aware of what’s current because I shop for clients all the time.
The Khaite bag helped kick off the studded bag trend and has been a cool New York City favorite for a while. I recently spotted a brown studded bag at Evereve that absolutely delivers the look for less and still feels high quality.
Hallie’s verdict: Evereve nails the vibe without the investment commitment.
Shop the Studded Bags:
Veronica Beard Shearling Boots vs. Birkenstock
Obsessed doesn’t even begin to cover it. I love the warmth of classic cozy boots, but I don’t always love how they look with outfits.
This Veronica Beard shearling-lined pair has been my go-to all winter. Birkenstock makes a very similar version at a friendlier price point. The Veronica Beard boots are currently on sale, final sale, and they run true to size.
Hallie’s verdict: Choose based on budget. Both keep you warm and look polished.
Shop the Shearling-Lined Boots:
Vitamix vs. Ninja Blender
I’ve had my Vitamix for years and use it daily for my blood sugar reset smoothies. It’s fantastic. That said, I needed a blender for my second home and didn’t want to invest in another Vitamix. I bought a cheap one in Florida that leaked and struggled with frozen fruit, so back it went.
I took a chance on the Ninja based on reviews, and honestly, it’s amazeballs. I may even like it better than the Vitamix. It has three blade levels, the blade comes out for easy cleaning, it holds more, and there’s an easy-pour spout. And it’s around $79. In this case, the look for less wins.
Hallie’s verdict: Shockingly, the Ninja wins. Same results, easier cleanup, and a much friendlier price.
Shop the Blenders:
Staud Beaded Bag vs. Anthropologie
This beaded clutch style that Staud helped popularize is not going anywhere. I love my Staud bag, but I’ll be honest: I reach for my Anthropologie version more often.
They offer classic styles along with some fun, kitschy options, and it’s a great way to try the trend without the higher price tag.
Hallie’s verdict: Anthropologie is the one you’ll actually use more often.
Shop the Bags:
Dyson Airwrap vs. Shark
I truly live for my Dyson Airwrap. I am not someone who can give herself a proper blowout at home, and this makes it possible.
My daughter Maggie wanted to take it to college. That was a firm no. She opted for the Shark instead, and according to her, it works just as well at a much more attainable price.
I will say this: I shared a one-day Dyson Airwrap sale on my Instagram Stories when QVC dropped the price to $399. If you want those kinds of real-time deals, make sure you’re following me on Instagram and actually watching my Stories.
Hallie’s verdict: Dyson is luxe, Shark is practical. Both get the job done beautifully.
Looks for less doesn’t mean settling. Sometimes it means finding the thing that works best for your life, your style, and your budget. And occasionally, it means realizing the less expensive option is the one you’d buy again.